403bwise is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization.

The K-12 403(b) is broken.
Together we can fix it.
Guest Blog from Scott Dauenhauer

Breaking Up Is Hard to Do

October 16, 2026

By Scott Dauenhauer, CFP®

Ashley Jackson recently became wise to her 403(b). She found the 403bwise.org Vendor Rating System (here) and realized she was paying unnecessary fees. In her school district’s 403(b) plan, she was sold a product from a well-known company that charged her an annual fee of 2.30%. Ashley had no idea she was paying so much in fees because the representative who sold her the product glossed over them.

When Ashley learned she could exchange her low-quality 403(b) product for a high-quality 403(b) from Fidelity Investments, she leaped at the opportunity.

Ashley opened an account at Fidelity, changed her Salary Reduction Agreement so future contributions would be deposited into Fidelity, and then called the low-quality company to find out what paperwork was needed to exchange her existing 403(b) assets into her new Fidelity 403(b). This is when Ashley learned about the surrender charge scam.

Looking at a $6,000 Surrender Charge

“Yes, Ms. Jackson, we can send you that paperwork, however when you surrender your contract you will have to pay a fee equal to 5% of any contribution made during the current and prior five contract years.” the low-quality 403(b) product company explained to Ashley.

Since Ashley has contributed an average of $20,000 per year over the last six years, her surrender charge would be $6,000. If she waited six more years, it would go to zero.

Understandably, Ashley was upset. This was her hard-earned money. Not only had she been overcharged on her account for years, but now she has to pay a fee to break up?

Ashley just learned the hard truth about the scam that is surrender charges in public education 403(b) plans.

Public education 403(b) plans are an outlier when it comes to surrender charges. Surrender charges are rare in the 401(k) world and are nonexistent in state-run defined contribution plans (403(b), 457(b), 401(a), and 401(k) plans). One of the largest retirement plans serving Federal employees is the Thrift Savings Plan; it has no surrender charges.

Public school educators are uniquely targeted.

Why Do Surrender Charges Exist?

When Ashley invested money into her 403(b), the representative who sold the 403(b) got paid a commission. The structure of 403(b) product commissions varies by product. In some cases, it’s a percentage of the dollar amount deposited each month; in others, it’s a much higher percentage of the amount of funds expected to be deposited over the next 12 months.

The methodology isn’t important; what matters is that the surrender charge exists because the 403(b) vendor advanced commissions on the product’s sale, and those commissions must be recouped over time. The participant must stay in the product and pay high fees so the vendor can recoup the commissions paid out at the point of sale. If the participant leaves the product before the vendor recovers the commissions, the participant is responsible for making the vendor whole.

Surrender charges do not exist for the good of participants; they exist because the public education K-12 403(b) plan is broken. Greedy companies uninterested in public educators’ long-term financial health have hijacked it.

The irony is that most representatives who sell 403(b) products have access to a 401(k) from their employer, and that plan has no surrender charges.

Ashley didn’t realize that she was making a twelve-year commitment to this company. Did I mention that the agent who sold her the policy left the company three years ago, and she hasn’t heard from anyone since? Ashley was ghosted, but she was still on the hook for a $6,000 break-up fee. Of course, she could choose to stay in this relationship for another six years (paying high fees) to avoid the break-up fee, but would that be wise?

97% Reduction in Fees

Ashley must decide whether to leave her existing 403(b) money with the low-quality, high-cost vendor until the surrender charge goes to zero in six years, or move it to her new, high-quality 403(b) vendor, Fidelity.

Ashley’s account at the low-quality vendor is now valued at $150,000. A 2.30% fee on $150,000 is $3,450 per year. If that money were held at Fidelity, it would be charged 0.08% or $115, a near 97% reduction in fees. Including the $24 in annual Fidelity charges, the reduction is 96%. This saves $3,311 per year. It would take roughly one year and 10 months for Ashley to break even (the savings from extra fees versus the initial break-up fee). In less than two years, Ashley would be ahead of the game by moving her money.

Breaking even is nice, but where will Ashley be in 25 years if she moves her money to Fidelity? She will be nearly $300,000 ahead of where she would have been if she had stayed with the low-quality vendor. You see, the surrender charge penalty is $6,000, but the real penalty is Ashley NOT moving her money.

Surrender Charges on Fixed Products

The financial product that led me to enter the 403(b) advocacy space was the Fixed Indexed Annuity (FIA) (formerly known as an Equity Indexed Annuity). FIAs quickly grew in popularity for two reasons: a story so good it was fake, and above-average compensation.

FIAs are financial products that lack the same level of regulation as variable annuities and mutual funds. State insurance commissioners, not the Securities and Exchange Commission, regulate them. State insurance commissioners do an incredibly poor job of regulating these products; the lack of accountability is shameful.

This lack of regulation and transparency (there is no public database available for proper research of FIAs) has allowed these products to flourish. I’m often asked if FIAs are good for retirement. My answer is always the same: yes, just not yours (they are very good for the representative selling them, though).

FIAs pay out hefty commissions and incentives to the agents who sell them. If you're unethical, selling FIAs to participants in 403(b) plans is your true North. While there are some reasonable FIAs, they are not available in public K-12 403(b) plans. The commissions on these products are significant, and if a representative sells enough of these awful products to unsuspecting educators, they might get to go on an incredible trip to Maui, the Bahamas, Italy, or even Monte Carlo. The only entities benefiting from the sale of these products are the insurance representative, the insurance company, and the insurance company’s investors.

The representative will excuse the presence of a surrender charge by saying these products are meant to be long-term. An insurance company might tell you they need long surrender periods and high surrender charges to stabilize payout rates. None of this is true. High surrender charges in FIAs sold in 403(b) plans exist to ensure the insurance company gets reimbursed for the money it spent trying to get you to buy the product in the first place. The surrender charge YOU pay is intended to compensate the insurance company for commissions and incentives it has already paid out.

There is no need for surrender charges in K-12 403(b) plans.

"Benefit Sensitive" Surrender Charges

I’m often told the surrender charge is fine because the company has created exceptions for people who are retiring. This is often called the “benefit sensitive” provision. Basically, surrender charges apply to everyone in the product, but certain participants have them waived if they meet specific criteria, such as retirement or disability (criteria vary by product and company). These products are no less of a scam than those that don’t offer this “benefit”. 

Don’t fall for the marketing. Good retirement plans do not have surrender charges.

...

Scott Dauenhauer CFP® is a fiduciary advisor and the owner of Meridian Wealth Management. He is also the Director of Research for 403bwise.org

{/exp:channel:entries}